MIME-Version: 1.0 Content-Type: multipart/related; boundary="----=_NextPart_01DACFBF.1DC65010" Данный документ является веб-страницей в одном файле, также называемой файлом веб-архива. Если вы видите это сообщение, значит данный обозреватель или редактор не поддерживает файлы веб-архива. Загрузите обозреватель, поддерживающий веб-архивы, например Microsoft Internet Explorer. ------=_NextPart_01DACFBF.1DC65010 Content-Location: file:///C:/01612227/file2951.htm Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable Content-Type: text/html; charset="us-ascii"
Supplement 3. Assessing the
quality of included systematic reviews by AMSTAR-2
First author=
, year |
1. Did the research questions and inclusion crit=
eria
for the review include the components of PICO? |
2. Did the report of the review contain an expli=
cit
statement that the review methods were established prior to conduct of the
review and did the report justify any significant deviations from the
protocol? |
3. Did the review authors explain their selectio=
n of
the study designs for inclusion in the review? |
4. Did the review authors use a comprehensive
literature search strategy? |
5. Did the review authors perform study selectio=
n in
duplicate? |
6. Did the review authors perform data extractio=
n in
duplicate? |
7. Did the review authors provide a list of excl=
uded
studies and justify the exclusions? |
8. Did the review authors describe the included
studies in adequate detail? |
9. Did the review authors use a satisfactory
technique for assessing the risk of bias (RoB) in individual studies that
were included in the review? |
10. Did the review authors report on the sources=
of
funding for the studies included in the review? |
11. If meta-analysis was performed did the review
authors use appropriate methods for statistical combination of results? |
12. If meta-analysis was performed, did the revi=
ew authors
assess the potential impact of RoB in individual studies on the results of
the meta-analysis or other evidence synthesis? |
13. Did the review authors account for RoB in
individual studies when interpreting/discussing the results of the review=
? |
14. Did the review authors provide a satisfactory
explanation for, and discussion of, any heterogeneity observed in the res=
ults
of the review? |
15. If they performed quantitative synthesis did=
the
review authors carry out an adequate investigation of publication bias (s=
mall
study bias) and discuss its likely impact on the results of the review? |
16. Did the review authors report any potential
sources of conflict of interest, including any funding they received for
conducting the review? |
J.H. Yoon et al., 2023 [9] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
S.E. Hickman et al., 2023 [10]<= o:p> |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Yes |
L.T. Thong et al., 2023 [18] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Yes |
X. Zheng et al., 2022 [21] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Yes |
=
No |
M. Liu et al., 2023 [55] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
No |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
T. Sugibayashi et al., 2023 [17] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
No |
=
No |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
R.Y.L. Kuo et al., 2022 [11] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
X. Zhang et al., 2022 [16] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
No |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
J.R. Lex et al., 2023 [13] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
No |
=
Yes |
P. Potipimpanon et al., 2022 [32] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
C.A. Campello et al, 2023 [30]<= o:p> |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
F. Nabizadeh et al., 2023 [46] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Yes |
M.Din et al., 2023 [25] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Yes |
M.D. Jшrgensen et al., 2023 [56] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
H.Y. Kim et al., 2021 [43] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
A. Adamou et al., 2023 [45] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
S. Agarwal et al., 2023 [22] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Yes |
S. Bedrikovetski et al., 2021a =
[23] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
S. Soffer et al., 2023 [36] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
No |
=
Yes |
C. Yang et al., 2022 [40] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
No |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
L. Gao et al., 2021 [14] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
No |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
R. Rescinito et al., 2023 [33] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Yes |
Q. Wang et al., 2022 [29] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
T.N. Poly et al., 2021 [15] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
No |
=
Yes |
T.E. Komolafe et al., 2023 [28]=
|
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
F. Abesi et al., 2023 [34] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
F.F. Badr, F.M. Jadu, 2022 [35] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
No |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
W. Xing et al., 2023 [20] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
N. Menon et al., 2023 [19] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
No |
=
No |
B.G. Taib et al., 2023 [39] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
No |
S. Sadr. et al., 2023 [27] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Yes |
=
No |
M. Islam et al., 2022 [37] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
K. Evangelista et al., 2022 [57] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
No |
=
Yes |
Y. Xue et al., 2022 [12] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
H.L. Xu et al., 2022 [26] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
E.A. Dumitrescu et al., 2022 [31] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Yes |
S. Bedrikovetski et al., 2021b =
[24] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
Y. Xu et al., 2021 [38] |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Partly
yes |
=
No |
=
Yes |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
No |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Not
applicable |
=
Yes |
=
Yes |
=
No |